| 1864 | | | | John Carlin : Honorary M.A., 1864 |
| 1866 | | | | Melville Ballard : B.S., 1866 ; M.S., 1870 |
| 1869 | | | | James Cross, Jr. : 1869 (2 years) |
| | | | James Denison : Honorary M.A., 1869 |
| | | | James Henry Logan : B.A., 1869 ; M.A., 1874 ; Hon. Sc. D., 1914 |
| | | | John Burton Hotchkiss : B.A., 1869 ; M.A., 1874 ; Honorary Litt. D., 1904 |
| | | | Joseph Griffin Parkinson : B.A., 1869 ; M.A., 1874 |
| | | | J. Scott Hutton : Honorary M.A., 1869 |
| 1870 | | | | Adelaide Smith : 1870 |
| | | | Anne Szymanoskie : 1870 |
| | | | Charles Baker : Honorary Ph.D., 1870 |
| | | | David Buxton : Honorary Ph.D., 1870 |
| | | | Emma J. Speake : 1870 |
| | | | Harvey P. Peet : Honorary Ph.D., 1870 |
| | | | Isaac Winn : B.A., 1870 |
| | | | John A. Burnet : Honorary M.A., 1870 |
| | | | Louis A. Houghton : B.A., 1870 |
| | | | Louis B. Tuck : B.A., 1870 ; Honorary M.A., 1904 |
| | | | Robert Patterson : B.A., 1870 ; M.A., 1883 ; Litt.D., 1904 |
| | | | Samuel T. Greene : B.A., 1870 |
| | | | William L. Bird : B.A., 1870 |
| | | | William W. Turner : Honorary Ph.D., 1870 |
| 1871 | | | | George W. McAtee : 1871 |
| | | | John H. Tims : 1871 |
| | | | John Quinn : 1871 |
| | | | Lydia Kennedy : 1871 |
| | | | Malachi Hallowell : 1871 (less than 1 year) |
| | | | Phillip S. Engelhardt : 1871 (3 years) |
| | | | William Taylor : 1871 |